
Lies of P: Complete Edition
Genre: Action-RPG
Players: 1
.
Review:
Lies of P is a “Soulslike”-style Action-RPG released in 2023 on PC, Mac OS, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One, with the Nintendo Switch 2 receiving a port of the game in 2026 in the form of this Complete Edition containing all DLC and post-launch updates. This game reimagines the classic Pinocchio story with players taking the role of the titular P, a human-like “puppet” automaton helping the last remnants of humanity in the steampunk-esque city of Krat after it was plagued by a mysterious illness followed by a bloody puppet uprising. Players must fight off rogue puppets, antagonistic humans with their own goals, and humans mutated by the disease as they piece together what’s happening and how to help what remains of humanity.
I’ll make it a point to say now, I noted in my review of Elden Ring Tarnished Edition that “Soulslike” games just don’t appeal to me the same way they do to others. As I noted there, it’s not due to a lack of skill, but just a general dislike for this style of gameplay. So if you’re looking for an objective view from someone who loves that style of game… well, you’ll have to go somewhere else, because I can only offer my own objective thoughts here, my own experience playing the game.
And… yeah, this is a “Soulslike”, all right. Which to me too often means clunky, cumbersome combat that players are nevertheless expected to perfectly adapt to in order to get past the challenges this game presents. To be sure, there are two easier difficulty settings players can opt to take here that are more forgiving and make for a less grueling adventure, but even playing the game this way I still felt the combat was far from thrilling. Players have a few different options for attacks, and much of the nuance here comes from dodging and blocking or deflecting attacks.
This game also offers players a way to customize their weaponry, with each combination of sword blade and hilt giving players a unique attack, but these attacks charge as you defeat enemies, a process that is slow enough that you won’t be doing this often. The same goes for healing, which recharges as you fight (slowly). You can also upgrade different stats and abilities through level-ups purchased using the same currency you use in shops and for other upgrades, but these upgrades are minimal, making even grinding agonizingly slow.
Despite my general distaste for the gameplay, I still can’t help but appreciate this game for its fascinating world, imaginative character designs, and engaging story (or lore, as is often the case in Soulslikes). And the Nintendo Switch 2 version of the game doesn’t seem obviously-compromised in any way I can see here – the game still features smooth framerates, a clear resolution, great visual effects, excellent lighting and shadows… it’s not the prettiest game on Nintendo Switch 2 or the most technically-stunning, but it’s solid in both areas.
I hate reviewing games like Lies of P that so many others have praised, because I know some of my dislike for the game comes from personal preference. But at the same time, I strain to see what others see in this. The unsatisfying combat, the slow progression… I hate to play out the Professor Skinner “no, it’s the children who are wrong” meme, but again, I can only comment on what I played, and what I played in Lies of P was a decent but not great game set in a fascinating, wondrously dark world that I wish I was enjoying more than I am. But if you are the sort of player who enjoys “Soulslike” games, I can at least report that this one plays wonderfully on Nintendo Switch 2, and I imagine you’ll enjoy it just fine.
tl;dr – Lies of P is a “Soulslike”-style Action-RPG loosely inspired by Pinocchio, with players taking the role of the titular P, an automaton fighting rogue “puppet” robots to try to help the last remnants of humanity. This game’s world is delightfully inspired, but I can’t enjoy this game when I feel like the combat is clunky and unsatisfying, and the progression is slow and frustrating. If you enjoy Soulslike games, you may find this one to your liking, and it plays very well on Nintendo Switch 2. But this is a game I can’t wholeheartedly recommend, despite its good qualities.
Grade: B-
You can support eShopperReviews on Patreon! Please click HERE to become a Sponsor!
This month’s sponsors are Jamie and His Cats, Ben, Ilya Zverev, Andy Miller, Johannes, Jaka, Jared Wark, Gabriel Coronad-Medina, Francis Obst, Kristoffer Wulff, Seth Christenfeld, and Vince Verrinoldi. Thank you for helping to keep the reviews coming!

Leave a Reply